WealthArch Blog

The WealthArch Blog

Sequence-of-Returns Risk: The Hidden Threat to Your Retirement

post on

Person reviewing portfolio investment growth rates on paper

Key Takeaways:

  • Sequence-of-returns risk is especially critical in retirement, as early market downturns inflict lasting damage because investors must sell more investments to cover living expenses. 
  • The years immediately before and after retirement, also known as the “retirement red zone,” are the most vulnerable period since portfolios are at their peak and losses compound before recovering. 
  • Maintaining appropriate cash reserves and dividing portfolios into short-, intermediate-, and long-term buckets prevents forced selling during market downturns. 
  • Building a well-diversified portfolio and establishing multiple income sources minimizes the need to make costly withdrawals from your investments during bad markets. 

Say your investment portfolio averages 7% a year. Most people hear that and assume it grows at that rate every year, but that’s hardly how it works. Some years your portfolio gains while others bring losses.  

In retirement, the order of those gains and losses matters just as much as the average return, sometimes even more. Two investors can earn the same average return over 30 years and still end up with very different portfolio balances, depending on when they experienced losses or withdrew their money. 

This gap is known as sequence-of-returns risk in retirement. 

What Is Sequence of Returns Risk? 

Put simply, sequence-of-returns risk is the danger that market turbulence early in retirement will damage your portfolio more than the same drop later on. 

The difference mainly comes down to withdrawals. When you’re still working and contributing to your investments, a market downturn may hurt less. You can continue investing and even take advantage of lower prices by buying more shares or assets. 

In retirement, however, you are taking money out to cover your living expenses. 

A Hypothetical Example of Sequence-of-Returns Risk in Retirement 

Say you need $75,000 a year to live on. When the market falls, your investments are worth less, so you sell more to raise that same $75,000. E.g., if prices fall by half, you sell twice as many shares. Those shares are gone for good, so they can’t recover when the market does. 

Unfortunately, if this happens early in retirement, you still have decades of withdrawals ahead. And so you keep pulling from a shrunken balance year after year. 

By contrast, a market downturn later in retirement may have less of a lasting impact. Your portfolio has had more time to benefit from investment gains, and with fewer years of withdrawals remaining, you’re less likely to sell investments at depressed prices repeatedly.

The Retirement “Red Zone” 

The riskiest stretch is the years immediately before and after you retire, often called the retirement red zone. Because your portfolio is typically at its peak right as you begin making withdrawals for retirement, sequence-of-returns risk can do the most damage during this critical window.

This doesn’t mean sequence risk disappears after the first five years. Market downturns can affect your portfolio at any stage of retirement. The early years are simply more vulnerable because losses and withdrawals can compound before your portfolio has had time to recover. 

Retirement Requires a Different Investment Mindset 

Younger investors can wait out a market drop, but people preparing for retirement must look for ways to reduce sequence-of-returns risk. 

This is a good example of where WealthArch Investment Services’ value investing approach proves its worth. While no strategy eliminates risk, we focus on undervalued stocks that trade well below the business’s intrinsic value, creating a margin of safety. 

This provides a crucial buffer when markets drop, protecting against the permanent losses that make sequence-of-returns risk in retirement so costly. This brings up the next key point… 

How to Reduce Sequence-of-Returns Risk 

Now that we understand what sequence-of-returns risk is and why it matters when planning for retirement, let’s look at several strategies investors can use to bolster their portfolio. 

You can’t control when the next market downturn will happen, but you can control how much damage it does. 

1. Maintain an Appropriate Cash Reserve 

One way to protect your portfolio is to keep enough money readily available to cover near-term living expenses. This reduces the need to sell stocks or other investments at depressed prices just to generate retirement income. 

That being said, holding too much cash has its own drawbacks. Most savings accounts offer less long-term growth potential than other assets, and inflation gradually erodes purchasing power. 

The right balance to reduce sequence-of-returns risk in retirement is to maintain enough liquidity to cover needs without sacrificing too much of your portfolio’s growth potential. 

2. Use a Bucket Strategy 

This approach tackles what sequence-of-returns risk is known for- forced selling in a downturn- by dividing your portfolio into portions based on when you’ll need the money. 

  • Short-term bucket: Cash and cash equivalents to cover immediate and near-term living expenses. 
  • Intermediate-term bucket: Relatively stable investments, like high-quality bonds and real estate, to support spending over the next several years. 
  • Long-term bucket: Growth-oriented investments that help your portfolio keep pace with inflation and fund future expenses. 

When your stocks perform well, it may make sense to trim some of those gains and move them into your cash or intermediate-term buckets. 

Bucket strategies still require regular rebalancing, so it’s best to develop them with an experienced investment manager. 

3. Build a Diversified Portfolio 

Diversification reduces the impact of poor performance in any one investment or asset class. By combining stocks, bonds, cash, and other suitable investments, you give your portfolio multiple ways to respond to changing market conditions. 

It’s also important to avoid concentration in a particular industry or sector. A well-diversified portfolio should limit the damage from a downturn in one area. 

4. Layer Your Income 

Another way to manage sequence-of-returns risk in retirement is to build multiple income sources to cover your living expenses. Some examples include Social Security benefits, pension payments, dividends, bond interest, rental income, annuity payments, and more. 

The more of your essential expenses these sources cover, the less you’ll need to withdraw from your investment portfolio. 

Prepare Your Portfolio for Retirement’s Uncertainties 

Ultimately, reducing sequence-of-returns risk comes down to preparing for market conditions and life changes you can’t predict. 

At WealthArch, we take a disciplined, value-oriented approach to investing with an emphasis on capital preservation and downside protection. We help our clients build personalized investment strategies that account for their income needs and risk tolerance. 

Concerned about how sequence-of-returns risk may affect your retirement goals? Schedule a free, no-commitment consultation with our advisors today.


Please feel free to share our post!