
Most people claim Social Security benefits as soon as they become eligible, without considering the trade-offs. However, taking benefits early isn’t always the best financial strategy.
Deciding when to start taking Social Security requires a break-even analysis and consideration of your retirement savings, investments, spousal benefits, and more.
At WealthArch Investment Services, this is a key decision our clients face when planning for retirement. Here are the steps we think anyone approaching eligibility age should consider.
Key Takeaways:
- Claiming at 62 permanently reduces Social Security benefits, but delaying until 70 increases monthly benefits beyond what one would receive at full retirement age (67).
- A Social Security break-even analysis shows the exact point where the larger checks from delaying catch up to the total early collections, but it is only a tool, not a verdict.
- Expected longevity, spouse’s potential survivor benefits, available retirement income, and taxes can all influence which claiming strategy makes the most financial sense.
- The best financial decision considers how claiming early or delaying will affect an individual’s investment balances, retirement account withdrawals, and ability to maintain a reliable income throughout retirement.
1. Review Your Estimated Social Security Benefits at 62, 67, and 70
Claiming Social Security at age 62 vs. 67 vs. 70 is a choice you live with for the rest of your life.
You can start receiving your benefits at 62, but doing so means accepting a permanently reduced monthly payment. Waiting longer increases your benefit, with the highest monthly amount generally available when you delay claiming until age 70.
How to Calculate Your Benefits
To decide when to start taking Social Security, compare the estimated monthly and annual payments at each age. You can find these figures through your Social Security Statement or the Social Security Administration’s (SSA) retirement estimator.
Keep in mind that 67 is the full retirement age for people born in 1960 or later. If you were born before 1960, your full retirement age may be slightly earlier, depending on your birth year.
2. Calculate Your Social Security Break-Even Age
One key way to compare your claiming options is through a Social Security break-even analysis.
The early claimant collects more checks, but the later claimant collects bigger ones. At some age, however, the later claimant’s total passes the early claimant’s. Your break-even age is when waiting for higher payments catches up to claiming early.
For example, imagine your estimated monthly benefits are:
|
Claiming Age |
Monthly Benefit |
|
62 |
$1,400 |
|
67 |
$2,000 |
|
70 |
$2,480 |
If you claim at 62, you’ll receive about $84,000 in benefits before someone who waits until 67 starts collecting.
However, the person who waits until 67 gets an additional $600 per month. To make up the $84,000 difference, they would need to collect the higher benefit for another 11 years and eight months. In this simplified example, the two options break even after age 78.
You can use any online calculator to compare claiming Social Security at 62 vs. 67 vs. 70. The results also show how much longevity matters when deciding when you should start taking Social Security.
Use It Only as a Starting Point
Note that a Social Security break-even analysis shouldn’t be your only consideration. A basic comparison doesn’t account for factors such as taxes, potential investment returns on benefits received earlier, inflation, or how your claiming decision affects your spouse’s survivor benefits.
It also assumes you can accurately predict how long you’ll live, which isn’t possible. Your best age to claim Social Security benefits depends on how these numbers fit into your health and financial circumstances.
3. Think About Your Health and How Long You Might Live
Speaking of life expectancy, deciding when to start taking Social Security is really a bet on how long you’ll live. No one knows that number, though your health and family history offer clues.
Remember, unfortunately, good health doesn’t guarantee a long life, so these considerations only help estimate potential longevity.
Beyond your Social Security break-even age, ask: Would the higher monthly payments from delaying Social Security provide valuable financial security later in life? This brings up our next consideration…
4. Evaluate Your Retirement Income Needs and Available Resources
Your decision about when to start taking Social Security should also consider how much income you’ll need throughout retirement and where that income will come from. The more of your spending you can cover from other sources, the more room you have to wait.
Other sources of income can include:
- Pensions
- Withdrawals from retirement accounts like 401(k)s, IRAs, and others
- Personal savings and investments
- Part-time or consulting work
On the other hand, if you need Social Security to cover essential expenses as soon as you retire, delaying your claim may not be practical.
5. Consider Your Spouse and Survivor Income
If you’re married, the time you start taking Social Security can also determine how much your spouse receives if you pass away. When one spouse dies, the survivor may qualify to receive up to 50% of the larger of the two Social Security benefits.
However, the timing of the claim affects the benefit amount. If a spouse files early, the benefit will be reduced to as low as 32.5%. This reduction is calculated based on the number of months before you claim full retirement benefits.
Spousal and survivor benefit calculations also depend on marital history, age, and earnings records.
6. Review the Tax Implications
The monthly benefit amount on your Social Security statement isn’t necessarily what you’ll have available to spend. Depending on your filing status and income, up to 85% of your benefits may be subject to federal income tax.
The IRS determines how much of your benefits may be taxable based on your combined income, which generally includes your adjusted gross income, nontaxable interest, and half of your Social Security benefits.
Other income sources, like withdrawals from pensions and traditional IRAs and 401(k)s, can also make more of your Social Security benefits taxable.
7. Evaluate How It Affects Your Portfolio
Your investments also affect when you should start taking Social Security because if you wait to claim, you’ll likely draw more from your portfolio in the early years of retirement to cover your expenses.
However, that raises the stakes if the market drops at the wrong time. Sequence-of-returns risk is especially costly in retirement, which is why the best age to claim Social Security benefits also depends on your cash flow and investment portfolio.
Looking at everything together, not just your Social Security break-even analysis, helps you make decisions that won’t strain your portfolio.
So, Should You Claim Social Security at 62, 67, or 70?
There isn’t one universally correct answer for when you should start taking Social Security, but the steps above give you a place to start.
Each one affects the others, and that’s where personalized professional guidance helps. An experienced financial advisor can help you compare different claiming scenarios and evaluate their impact on your portfolio.
At WealthArch, we help clients review these moving parts together and build retirement strategies around their long-term financial goals.
Not sure which age is right for you? Schedule a free consultation with our team today.





